Gaming journalism is a complex beast. A paradox. Access is something most journalism needs, but to gaming outlets, it’s absolutely critical.
Gaming journalism is, by some accounts, a broken field. By others, its unjournalistic process is a symptom of reporting online, where advertising revenue is minimal, at least when compared to revenue from newspapers or magazines. And that isn’t just exclusive to gaming journalism — most outlets, both online and in print, face an uncertain future under the weight of a change in the way we absorb news and opinion. (The change is evident when you account for how many sites have recently undergone a design to accommodate tablets better. USgamer, Kotaku and Polygon among others.)
Destructoid highlighted one of the primary issues in March when its founder, Niero Gonzalez, wrote a piece detailing the site’s rampant problem with ad blocking software. Writing for a nerd savvy audience, he posited that half of Destructoid‘s readership blocks ads, eliminating half of the revenue stream. For game writers the salaries are already bad, with not much room to improve, but to get paid for half an audience is part of the business. It’s trying to survive in an online world.
That’s why gaming press seems like a corrupt industry, when it should be incorruptible. Corporate apologetics, publisher-granted exclusive reviews, mostly non-hard-hitting, superfluous bits to appease the companies. All of this is how modern journalism operates. (As an experiment, check notable outlets or magazines and look for the term “sponsored content”. More sites do it than you’d think.) But when the revenue stream is one-tenth of historical norms, journalists must find ways to continue writing, and that sometimes involves looking for sponsors. It’s not optimal, it’s not prestigious, it goes everything I learned in journalism school, but hey, money rules the world.
Exclusive reviews are a rarity these days. Though, when IGN scored BioShock Infinite‘s first review four days before competing outlets, it exhibited again how gaming journalists appear to be in bed with publishers. And of course, publishers will use the publicity to their advantage because free marketing helps sell a game. It’s a win-win-lose situation: IGN makes a boatload, 2K gets advertising through scandal, and sites like Destructoid are left to voice their displeasure on social media.
This problem is especially bad given how “journalism” is often used as a stepping stone to other opportunities. Most people looking to gain entry into gaming go the route of gaming journalism, only to find themselves catapulting to PR positions. Again, it’s a matter of necessity because salaries are notoriously low. Want to start a family? Try doing that on $25000 a year. But writing about anything in the modern age is more of a passion project, or should be, especially because the chance to leapfrog to an editorial position or higher is low as well.
For outlets, too, the constant threat of blacklisting from events exist, for the journalistic responsibility of reporting the news. In early 2012, Activision blacklisted a french gaming blog after it reported that Black Ops would get a sequel. That launched a semi-serious debate over journalist ethics in reporting, and if a business relationship with Activision overshadowed covering the story. The publisher relented later in a quote to Kotaku, who had put up a scathing interview with Gameblog.fr’s founder. (Give it a read.)
Access to games and prominent figures is paramount if gaming journalism should continue to exist. Because, as a readership, we’ve dictated that reviews and interviews are the most buzzworthy articles, therefore creating an interesting paradox. We demand better journalism, but the readership is also a source of the problem. Not the only source though, as the many improper things done by the journalists themselves are inexcusable. But that’s another post.
I hate using the term “necessary evil”, but nothing applies more perfectly.
What do you think of the problem? And do you even care, or is this so institutionalized that it doesn’t bother you?
If you like this post, please share it with a button below. It helps grow the blog! As well, follow Holygrenade on Facebook and twitter from the sidebar, and reach me with a tab above. Holygrenade also does submissions if you want something you’ve written to appear on the site. Enjoy your Tuesday!
Share, would you kindly?
Holygrenade on Twitter
- © 2013 Holygrenade. All images are copyrighted by their respective owners.